The rising cost of earthquake insurance

Desk reporter Harshawn Ratanpal digs into why earthquake insurances costs are up on the New Madrid fault, leading to fewer people with coverage

A man stands in a parking lot smiling beside a Farm Bureau New Madrid County sign
A man stands in a parking lot smiling beside a Farm Bureau New Madrid County sign
Missouri Farm Bureau Agent Jason Ginder stands outside of his office in New Madrid, Mo. Although major earthquakes wiped out the town in the early 1800s, most New Madrid citizens do not have earthquake insurance today. Credit: Hannah Schuh, Columbia Missourian

There has been plenty of news about the skyrocketing cost of living the last few years. But here's a new one: Desk reporter Harshawn Ratanpal of KBIA in Columbia, Missouri, dug into a massive increase in earthquake insurance policy premiums on the infamous New Madrid fault, a staggering 800% change in just two decades.

This piece is part of a series on the New Madrid fault he's working on with the Desk, and he shared a bit about why it matters to so many people.

Here's Harshawn:

A headshot of a young man smiling outside
Desk reporter Harshawn Ratanpal (KBIA)

"When a colleague and I visited the town of New Madrid late last year, we wanted to answer why so few people had earthquake insurance. The main takeaway of our first visit was that preparing for the earthquake wasn’t a priority for people. To them, there were bigger issues to deal with: pocketbook and kitchen table issues that affect them much more than fault lines beneath their feet.

But while writing the first piece we published, I knew there were more complicated causes and effects to discuss.

Why is earthquake insurance eight times more expensive than it was in 2000 and why do only about 11% of people have it, down from 60% in 2000? To find out, we reached out to economists, underwriters, government officials and local brokers. The answers to these simple questions were complicated and nuanced.

We found that a mix of factors — including updated risk models, pseudoscientific scares that shook confidence in disaster prediction, and a lack of political will to do much about the issue —  created a seemingly endless upward trajectory of price and therefore a downward trend of coverage.

A line graph shows earthquake insurance annual costs have risen consistently in New Madrid from 2022-2000
Data from Harshawn's reporting illustrating the rising cost of earthquake insurance in New Madrid. (Chart by CJ Christy with data from Missouri DCI)

Insurance isn’t the most exciting topic, and it can be especially tough to write about something that may not happen for a long time, like a major earthquake. But this story reminded me why I love reporting. I love that we get the opportunity to get lost in a brand new topic, drilling deeper and deeper until we have something groundbreaking to share with all of you.

Thank you for reading and stay tuned for the next piece about New Madrid and its people."

Michael here again.

You can read the full insurance piece here. KBIA also made a nice Instagram reel with Harshawn discussing this series that's worth checking out here.

Thanks for reading. More next week from across the Basin.

Sincerely,

Michael Crowe
Operations Manager,
Ag & Water Desk

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Mississippi River Basin Ag & Water Desk.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.